Overview of Charles Schwab and Cash App
For most of the last century, trading in the stock market usually meant being on Wall Street or knowing someone who was. Mobile technology has changed that completely. In this article, we compare two popular investment platforms, Cash App and Charles Schwab. We’ll review their investment options, costs, platforms, and any special features they offer.
Costs
Services
| Broker Review |
Cost |
Investment Products |
Trading Tools |
Customer Service |
Research |
Overall Rating |
|
Charles Schwab
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Cash App
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Available Assets and Accounts
The biggest difference between Cash App and Charles Schwab is that Cash App is mainly a mobile payment app, while Charles Schwab is a full-service brokerage and financial institution.
Over time, Cash App has gone through several changes, including rebranding and the gradual addition of investing features that allow users to trade stocks and bitcoin. While its investment choices are limited, Cash App is built around a simple, easy-to-use interface. This simplicity helps it reach a broader audience than traditional brokerage firms, which tend to have more complex platforms. Cash App’s investment offerings are limited compared to Schwab, with access to only about 1,000 stocks. Bitcoin is the only cryptocurrency available.
By contrast, Charles Schwab is a full-service brokerage firm that works closely with its banking and financial services division. Together, they offer a wide range of financial products, including stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs, options, and futures. Schwab provides access to more than 4,000 no-transaction-fee mutual funds and over 3,000 commission-free ETFs. Investors can also trade in international markets and use professional portfolio management services.
To use Cash App’s features, you only need to create an account within the app. Schwab customers can trade through many different account types, including self-directed IRAs, retirement accounts, and solo 401(k)s.
Cash App is mainly self-service, while Schwab offers full financial advising and planning services. Schwab also provides a large library of educational materials for its clients.
Both companies allow unlimited internal fund transfers, links to outside accounts for moving money in and out, debit cards for cash withdrawals and purchases, and ACH direct deposits.
The Schwab mobile app supports mobile check deposits, while the Cash App mobile app allows cash deposits at participating retailers such as Walmart and Dollar Tree, where users can add cash at the register.
Cost
Cash App has a very simple fee structure. It does not charge commissions for stock trades, but it does charge a 3% fee to buy or sell Bitcoin.
Most of Cash App’s $1.8 billion in gross profit comes from charging a 1.5% fee for instant transfers from the app to a linked bank account.
Customers without direct deposit can withdraw money from ATMs using their debit card for a $2–$3 ATM fee. There is also a $1 fee to deposit cash at participating retailers.
One drawback is that although stock trades are commission-free, the price paid for a stock on Cash App is usually slightly higher than the market price. A benefit is that Cash App allows fractional share purchases, since trades are based on dollar amounts rather than whole shares.
Schwab does not charge commissions for online stock trades, though options trades have a $0.65 fee per contract.
Schwab does not charge ATM fees and will reimburse any fees charged by ATM operators when customers withdraw money from their accounts.
Platforms
Cash App does not offer a web or desktop trading platform. All stock trading is done through the mobile app, which follows a simple and easy-to-use layout. Stocks and bitcoin can be found by going to the home screen, scrolling down, and selecting the asset you want to trade.
Users can search for a specific stock and choose “buy” or “sell.” Cash App includes basic charts and news updates to help users stay informed.
After acquiring TD Ameritrade, Schwab now offers several platforms, including two desktop platforms, two web-based platforms, and the ThinkOrSwim mobile app. These platforms are more advanced and provide access to higher-risk, higher-reward trades, along with in-depth charting, research, and analysis tools.
ThinkOrSwim supports trading in stocks as well as mutual funds, ETFs, options, and index funds. Users can place many order types, including market, limit, stop-loss, and trailing stop orders. One of its biggest advantages is the ability to use a paper trading account to practice trading with simulated money.
Schwab also offers a wide range of educational tools, including videos and online presentations.
Extra Features
In 2020, Cash App announced the acquisition of Credit Karma Tax, a free DIY tax-filing service, and integrated it into its app. This makes tax filing a feature unique to Cash App and not available to Schwab customers. Cash App also offers a cash-back rewards program for users who spend with their Cash App card.
Schwab’s extra features include advanced tools such as charting, backtesting, trading scripts, automated trading, alerts, and customizable watchlists. Most importantly, Schwab provides access to professional portfolio management services.
Promotions
Charles Schwab: $0 commissions + ACAT rebate + satisfaction guarantee at Charles Schwab.
Cash App:
Use U2Q3HN referral link to get $10 cash bonus.
Charles Schwab vs Cash App Recommendations
In summary, Cash App is a strong choice for new investors who want to trade stocks, ETFs, and Bitcoin with minimal effort. However, investors who want access to a wider range of investments and more advanced research and analysis tools will likely find Charles Schwab to be the better choice.
For anyone looking to improve their trading skills, we recommend opening a Schwab brokerage account and using the ThinkOrSwim paper trading feature to practice trades and learn more advanced investment strategies.
|